Matter profitability: what every partner needs to know

Understanding the true cost of legal work

Matter profitability begins with a clear understanding of costs and efficient WIP management. While a matter might show impressive headline WIP, the real question is how much of this will convert to revenue. Less effectively managed matters often see WIP aging beyond 90 days, leading to write-offs that can slash profitability by 30% or more.

Consider a typical matter team: a partner (£600/hour), senior associate (£400/hour), and junior associate (£250/hour). The headline revenue for 100 hours of work would be £125,000. However, if 20% of WIP becomes uncollectable due to delayed billing or client disputes, the effective revenue drops to £100,000, potentially eliminating the entire profit margin.

Profit drivers: beyond the billable hour

While billable hours remain important, profitable partners focus heavily on WIP-to-cash conversion. Regular WIP reviews – ideally weekly for significant matters – enable early identification of potential billing issues. Top-performing partners typically maintain WIP levels at less than 45 days of billing, ensuring stronger cash flow and higher realisation rates.

Technology utilisation directly affects profitability through better WIP management. Modern matter management tools can flag aging WIP, unusual time entries, and budget overruns before they become write-off issues. One savvy partner the author knows reduced their average WIP days by 45 days through automated monitoring and proactive client communications.

Strategic staff allocation

Profitable matters require thoughtful team composition. Consider a due diligence exercise: traditionally, junior associates might spend 100 hours at £250/hour reviewing documents. However, using a combination of AI-powered review tools and paralegals (at £125/hour) could reduce costs while maintaining quality. The key is matching work complexity with appropriate resource levels.

Success often comes from building balanced teams. A profitable matter might be staffed with:

• Partner oversight and strategy (15% of hours)
• Senior associate management and complex work (25% of hours)
• Junior associate execution (40% of hours)
• Paralegal support (20% of hours)

This structure ensures work is handled at the appropriate level while maintaining quality and profitability.

Client selection: the foundation of profitability

Not all clients contribute equally to profitability. Smart partners evaluate potential clients against clear criteria:

• Payment history and financial stability
• Willingness to accept appropriate fee arrangements
• Potential for relationship growth
• Industry alignment with firm expertise
• Reasonable expectations about service and costs

One corporate partner the author knows increased their practice's profitability by 25% simply by becoming more selective about client acceptance and regularly evaluating client relationships against these criteria.

WIP Management: The Hidden Profit Driver

Successful partners treat WIP management as a critical daily task, not a monthly administrative burden. Key strategies include:

• Regular WIP reviews with clear actions: "Every Monday, I review WIP across all active matters. Anything over 30 days gets immediate attention."
• Progressive billing approaches: Instead of waiting for matter completion, bill progressively based on completed phases or monthly work. This reduces client surprise and improves cash flow.
• Early issue identification: When WIP on a £100,000 matter reaches £25,000, review progress against budget and discuss with the client before continuing.

Pricing strategies that drive profitability

Profitable partners employ sophisticated pricing strategies beyond hourly rates. Alternative fee arrangements (AFAs), when properly structured, can increase profitability while providing clients with desired predictability. For instance, a fixed fee matter priced at £200,000 might typically cost £150,000 to deliver, providing a healthy margin while incentivising efficiency.

Success with AFAs requires understanding your cost basis and efficiency capabilities. Phase-based pricing has proven particularly effective, allowing for clearer scope definition and better profit margin management. One litigation team the author knows found that breaking matters into discrete phases with individual budgets improved overall profitability by 30%.

Monitoring profitability

Regular monitoring of key metrics ensures sustained profitability. Successful partners track:

• Realisation rates (targeting above 90%)
• Work-in-progress aging (keeping it under 60 days)
• Resource utilisation across team members
• Technology ROI on a per-matter basis

Conclusion

Matter profitability requires consistent attention to both high-level strategy and day-to-day WIP management. Partners who master these elements while making informed decisions about resource allocation, technology investment, and client selection can build sustainable, profitable practices while delivering excellent client service.

The most successful partners understand that profitability management is an ongoing process requiring regular attention and adjustment. By focusing on the key drivers of matter profitability, including rigorous WIP management, and making data-driven decisions, partners can ensure their practices remain competitive and sustainable in an increasingly challenging legal market.

‍